How to Identify Valuable Antiques: 8 Evidence Checks
To identify a potentially valuable antique, check its marks, construction, materials, wear, repairs, provenance and rarity. Then compare recent sales of similar pieces. The first seven checks help establish what you have. The eighth helps you judge what buyers have actually paid.
1. Read the maker’s marks and hallmarks
Look underneath the base, inside a drawer or on the reverse. Photograph the whole piece and then the mark in good light. Copy the letters, symbols and their order exactly. On English silver, the sponsor’s mark, assay office mark and date letter answer different questions. A retailer’s label on furniture may tell you who sold it while leaving the maker an open question.
Our sterling silver sherry label depicting Bacchus is catalogued as Birmingham, 1932. The decoration helps you recognise the subject. The silver marks are where you would look to check the place and date.
2. Examine how the piece was made
Open a drawer and look at the corners, the underside and the way the runners meet the frame. On a small object, inspect hinges, seams and fastenings. A dovetail is one clue among several. Machines also cut dovetails, so the shape of a joint alone cannot establish age.
Our Edwardian walnut and brass bookslide expands to hold more books. Follow the sliding base from one end to the other. It is easier to understand the craftsmanship once you see which parts have to move together.

3. Identify the materials
Start with the surface and then inspect an exposed edge. On furniture, the edge can show where a decorative veneer meets the underlying timber. On metalware, examine high points for signs that a plated finish has worn through. Record what you can see before assigning a material or country of origin.
Consider our Australian-made trinket box with a bronze cherub. Its French styling describes the design. The bronze attribution applies to the cherub, and the box was made in Australia. Those details matter when looking for a comparable piece.
4. Look for wear where the piece was handled
On a cabinet, compare the timber around the handles with the surface inside a door. On a footed vessel, examine the contact points underneath. Ask whether the pattern makes sense for the way the object was used. A sheltered surface can look surprisingly fresh, even on a piece that has seen decades of use.
5. Check for repairs and replacements
Look for spare screw holes behind handles, a patch of veneer with a different grain, or a fine line crossing a porcelain rim. Describe the location and extent of any repair. A replaced drawer pull and a repaired load-bearing chair rail raise quite different questions for a buyer.
6. Trace the provenance
Provenance is the documented history of a particular object. An old receipt, auction catalogue entry or dated photograph is most helpful when a measurement, inscription or distinctive detail connects it to the piece in front of you. Write down family recollections too, including who supplied them and which details still need checking.
7. Investigate what makes the example rare
Identify the specific feature you think is unusual. Is it the size, pattern, maker, or survival of a complete set? Search for the ordinary version as well. For a covered dish, for example, check how often the same model appears with its matching lid. Scarcity contributes to value when buyers also want that feature.
8. Compare prices actually achieved
Look for recent sold examples with a similar maker, material, size and condition. For an Australian comparison, note the sale date, currency and whether the recorded auction price includes the buyer’s premium. Keep an asking price separate from a completed sale. If the closest result is a pair and yours is a single, record that difference before drawing a conclusion.
What should I photograph before asking an antique dealer?
Take a full view, the reverse or underside, a close-up of any marks and a clear photograph of any damage or repair. Include measurements and any paperwork that can be linked to the piece. These details give a dealer a better starting point than a front view alone.

See examples at Moonee Ponds Antiques
Browse our recently arrived antiques or explore our Melbourne antiques collection. To look more closely at a piece, visit our family showroom at 49–51 Hawker Street, Airport West, Victoria. The customer entrance is at 51 Hawker Street.
Further reading on furniture construction
The Metropolitan Museum of Art’s dovetailing machine record and the Library of Congress dovetailing machine record give historical context for the use of machinery in joinery.
Reviewed 19 November 2026.